SpudGunMan wrote:
Quote:
When the spec was to have a rigid HF antenna and mast collapse to 18" or less I realized commercial products wouldn't cut it.
the super antenna M1 is just that FYI
also the mini buddy pole portable would also fit into that
The mini-buddipole isn't a very rigid design as the whip is telescopic which I consider to be too flimsy for a field radio. Another problem is that it doesn't do 60/80 meters. The biggest problem is that they didn't seem to have time to respond to emails with product questions. I responded in kind by not finding time to purchase their products.
I looked at Super Antenna however I did not see any size/weight specifications on their website. This is kind of silly when they are selling products claiming to be portable. Their website doesn't specify what kind of whip they use however I doubt it is an 8-foot collapsible which is what I prefer. Their antenna is only good to 40 meters and appears to use an additional long non-tappable coil for 80 meters. This creates two problems as there is no place to tap for 60 meters and their coil design might not fit in the pack.
Like I said, commercial products didn't cut it.